Lillo's Tomato Pies

Located in the heart of Hainesport, NJ, Lillo's Tomato Pies stands out as an authentic destination for lovers of traditional South Jersey and Philadelphia-inspired fare. Specializing in both pizza and cheesesteaks, this cozy yet bustling eatery delivers a masterclass in comfort food elevated by quality ingredients and heartfelt craftsmanship.

The cuisine here is a proud nod to classic Italian-American and Philly flavors, with menu highlights that are as robust as they are inviting. Pizza enthusiasts will revel in the legendary Nonna Pie—a beautifully balanced, generously sized tomato pie boasting a sweet, savory sauce, fresh cheese, and a crust that strikes the perfect harmony between light crispness and chewy satisfaction. For those craving variety, specialty pies such as the Mustard Pie with Sausage and the Clams Casino Pie showcase Lillo’s knack for melding bold, traditional flavors with a refined edge.

But it’s the cheesesteaks that truly make Lillo’s a hometown hero. From the classic Plain Cheesesteak to the savory Cheesesteak Hoagie and the hearty Cheesesteak Salad, each sandwich is a generous, mouthwatering experience. Customers rave about perfectly crusted seeded rolls that hold up beautifully under heaps of tender, juicy steak and melted cheese, creating an irresistible melty, meaty amalgamation that’s been called “the best in South Jersey” by many devoted fans.

Beyond the mains, the menu offers enticing sides like golden, crispy French fries, cheese fries oozing with rich flavor, and intriguing options like house-made meatballs and mussels in white sauce—each bite layered with comforting depth. Hoagie lovers can indulge in Turkey or Italian varieties packed with fresh, quality fillings, making every meal mood-lifting and satisfying.

Dining at Lillo’s is not just about food; it’s also about the welcoming atmosphere crafted by the owners who take genuine pride in their craft and community. As shared by frequent guests, the warm hospitality adds a personalized touch that transforms every visit into a memorable experience. Whether you're grabbing a quick hoagie or settling in for a family pizza night, expect a friendly environment where the love for great food radiates through every plate.

In sum, Lillo’s Tomato Pies is a must-visit for anyone seeking an authentic taste of South Jersey’s best cheesesteaks and tomato pies. From the first bite of their crusty, flavorful pies to the last morsel of a succulent cheesesteak sandwich, this restaurant offers an unbeatable blend of rich tradition, fresh ingredients, and passionate execution that leaves customers eagerly planning their next return.

Contact: 2503 Marne Hwy, Hainesport, NJ 08036 | Phone: +1 609-491-7751