Lillo's Tomato Pies Menu

Lillo's Tomato Pies in Hainesport, NJ, is a gem for lovers of authentic South Jersey tomato pies and hearty cheesesteaks. Their menu boasts a variety of standout dishes that blend traditional flavors with fresh, quality ingredients. The signature Trenton Tomato Pie features a perfectly balanced crust, tangy yet slightly sweet tomato sauce, and a generous layer of cheese—huge and satisfying in portion. Equally impressive are their cheesesteaks, served on crusty seeded rolls that hold up to the savory, meaty fillings. From the classic Plain Cheesesteak to the indulgent Buffalo Chicken Cheesesteak, each sandwich packs bold flavors and ample protein, earning praise for being among the best in the region. Standout items like the Mustard Pizza with Sausage and the Roast Pork with Broccoli Rabe highlight the menu’s diverse range. Whether craving a light Caesar Salad with grilled chicken or hearty meatball parm sandwiches, Lillo’s delivers consistently generous portions and a warm, welcoming atmosphere that enhances every meal.